So interesting to read the previous review. I am new to this brand but I ordered 5 shirts. The red an white Quinn in Small- LOVE, perfect! The Hawaiian Small was tiny! The Signature Black Small was too tight in the shoulders and the velvety fabric bugs me a bit and it's an OFF black so not sure I like it... And the Signature Carnation Multi Small - LOVE, perfect!So I guess it depends... When they are right I really LOVE!